Skip to main content

Estimating Discount Rates

Cost of Equity and Cost of Capital

Estimating the appropriate discount rate is crucial for any valuation exercise. The discount rate reflects the riskiness of an investment and the required rate of return for investors. Two key components of the discount rate are the cost of equity and the cost of capital.

1. Cost of Equity (Ke):

  • Definition: The rate of return required by equity investors to compensate them for the risk of investing in a company's stock. It represents the opportunity cost of investing in that particular stock.
  • Importance: Used to discount cash flows to equity (FCFE) and dividends in the Dividend Discount Model (DDM).
  • Common Estimation Models:
    • Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM):
      • Formula: Ke = Rf + β * (Rm - Rf)
      • Rf (Risk-Free Rate): The return on a risk-free investment, typically a government bond.
      • β (Beta): A measure of a stock's systematic risk (i.e., its sensitivity to market movements).
      • Rm (Market Return): The expected return on the overall market.
      • (Rm - Rf) (Market Risk Premium): The additional return investors require for investing in the market rather than a risk-free asset.
      • Limitations: CAPM relies on several assumptions that may not hold in the real world, such as efficient markets and a linear relationship between risk and return.
    • Build-Up Approach:
      • Formula: Ke = Rf + Industry Risk Premium + Company-Specific Risk Premium
      • Industry Risk Premium: Reflects the average risk of companies in the same industry.
      • Company-Specific Risk Premium: Reflects the unique risks of the company, such as management quality, financial strength, and competitive position.
      • Applicability: Useful for private companies or when beta is unreliable. More subjective than CAPM.
    • Arbitrage Pricing Theory (APT):
      • Formula: Ke = Rf + β1 * Factor1 + β2 * Factor2 + ... + βn * Factor n
      • Factors: Macroeconomic or firm-specific factors that influence stock returns (e.g., inflation, interest rates, GDP growth).
      • Betas (β): Sensitivity of the stock to each factor.
      • Complexity: APT is more complex than CAPM and requires identifying and measuring relevant factors.
  • Considerations:
    • Estimating Beta: Historical betas can be calculated from past stock returns, but they may not be representative of future risk. Fundamental betas can be estimated based on the company's business characteristics.
    • Market Risk Premium: The market risk premium can vary over time and across different markets. Historical averages or surveys of investor expectations can be used to estimate the market risk premium.
    • Risk-Free Rate: Typically uses the yield on a long-term government bond to match the time horizon of the investment.

2. Cost of Capital (WACC):

  • Definition: The weighted average cost of all sources of financing used by a company, including debt, equity, and preferred stock. It represents the minimum rate of return that a company must earn on its investments to satisfy its investors.
  • Importance: Used to discount free cash flows to the firm (FCFF) in firm valuation.
  • Formula: WACC = (We * Ke) + (Wd * Kd * (1 - t)) + (Wp * Kp)
    • We (Weight of Equity): The proportion of equity in the company's capital structure.
    • Ke (Cost of Equity): As defined above.
    • Wd (Weight of Debt): The proportion of debt in the company's capital structure.
    • Kd (Cost of Debt): The yield to maturity on the company's outstanding debt.
    • t (Tax Rate): The company's marginal tax rate. Interest expense is tax-deductible, so the cost of debt is reduced by the tax rate.
    • Wp (Weight of Preferred Stock): The proportion of preferred stock in the company's capital structure.
    • Kp (Cost of Preferred Stock): The dividend yield on the company's preferred stock.
  • Determining Weights:
    • Market Values: Use market values of debt and equity, if available.
    • Target Capital Structure: If the company has a target capital structure, use those weights.
    • Book Values: Use book values if market values are not available.

Considerations:

  • Capital Structure: The company's capital structure can significantly impact its WACC.
  • Tax Rate: The tax rate can also have a significant impact on the WACC, as it affects the after-tax cost of debt.
  • Changing Capital Structure: If the company's capital structure is expected to change in the future, the WACC should be adjusted accordingly.
  • Project-Specific Discount Rates: For evaluating specific projects, it may be appropriate to use project-specific discount rates that reflect the unique risks of the project.

In summary, estimating the cost of equity and cost of capital involves a combination of quantitative analysis and qualitative judgment. Understanding the strengths and limitations of different estimation models is essential for arriving at a reasonable discount rate.

Back to top