Skip to main content

Principles and Process

1. Introduction

Capital budgeting is a crucial process for firms to allocate their financial resources to various investment proposals. The capital budgeting process involves generating, evaluating, selecting, and following up on capital expenditure alternatives.

2. Kinds of Capital Budgeting Decisions

Firms typically encounter three main types of capital budgeting decisions:

  1. Accept-Reject Decision
  2. Mutually Exclusive Choice Decision
  3. Capital Rationing Decision

2.1. Accept-Reject Decision

  • Fundamental Decision: This is a basic decision regarding whether to invest in a particular project or not.
  • Acceptance Criteria: Projects that yield a rate of return greater than the required rate of return (or the cost of capital) are generally accepted.
  • Rejection Criteria: Projects that do not meet this minimum return threshold are rejected.
  • Independent Projects: Under this decision, all independent projects that meet the criteria are implemented. Independent projects are those that don't compete with one another; accepting one doesn't preclude accepting others.

2.2. Mutually Exclusive Project Decisions

  • Competitive Projects: Mutually exclusive projects are those that compete with each other, meaning the acceptance of one automatically excludes the others.
  • Choice of One: Only one of the competing projects can be chosen.
  • Example: Selecting one out of several competing brands of machinery to purchase.
  • Combined Decision: These decisions are not independent of accept-reject decisions. The projects considered must also be acceptable under the accept-reject criterion.
    • If no project is acceptable in accept-reject decision, then no mutually exclusive projects should be chosen.
    • If multiple mutually exclusive projects are acceptable, a specific technique is used to choose the "best" project from these. The selection of the best project automatically eliminates the other alternatives.

2.3. Capital Rationing Decision

  • Limited Funds: In reality, firms rarely have unlimited funds; they usually have a fixed capital budget.
  • Competition for Funds: A large number of investment proposals compete for these limited resources.
  • Allocation of Funds: Firms must allocate funds to projects in a way that maximizes long-run returns.
  • Selection from Acceptable Projects: Capital rationing deals with selecting the best projects from a set of proposals deemed acceptable under the accept-reject decision.
  • Ranking: Capital rationing employs ranking of the acceptable investment projects based on a predetermined criterion such as the rate of return. The projects are ranked in descending order of rate of return.

3. Key Terminology

  • Accept-Reject Decision: The process of evaluating whether a capital expenditure proposal meets the minimum criteria for acceptance.
  • Mutually Exclusive Projects (Decisions): Projects that compete with one another; accepting one eliminates the others from consideration.
  • Capital Rationing: A financial situation where a firm has a fixed amount to allocate among competing capital expenditures.
  • Capital Budgeting Process: The four interrelated steps of evaluating and selecting long-term proposals: generation, evaluation, selection, and follow-up.
  • Independent Projects: Projects whose cash flows are unrelated; the acceptance of one does not eliminate others from consideration.
  • Unlimited Funds: The situation in which a firm can accept all independent projects that provide an acceptable return, which is rare in reality.

4. Conclusion

Capital budgeting involves not only evaluating individual projects but also making choices between competing projects and allocating limited resources effectively. The accept-reject, mutually exclusive, and capital rationing decisions are core aspects of this process that firms must navigate to optimize their financial strategies.

Back to top